A Guide to Kentucky[B] Reserve Study Laws: Understanding Your HOA's Financial Future

Kentucky Reserve Study Laws vs. a Board's Fiduciary Duty

For board members of homeowners associations (HOAs) and condo associations in Kentucky, understanding the state's position on reserve funds is the first step to sound financial management.

The legal situation in Kentucky presents a specific obligation. While Kentucky state law does not explicitly mandate that HOAs or condo associations conduct a formal reserve study, the Kentucky Horizontal Property Law (KRS 381.870) does require that "all co-owners contribute toward the expense of maintaining a replacement reserve". Furthermore, the Kentucky Condominium Act (KRS 381.9167) grants associations the power to "adopt and amend budgets for... reserves".¹

This creates a crucial link: the state requires funding a replacement reserve, but doesn't specify how much. This is where a board's fiduciary duty comes into play. This legal standard requires Kentucky board members to act in the "best interest of the association", make "informed decisions", and exercise "prudent fiscal management". This duty includes ensuring the association complies with the law—including the requirement to fund a replacement reserve.²

Many Kentucky boards might focus only on the lack of a study mandate, potentially underfunding the legally required reserve. This is a critical—and potentially costly—misunderstanding. How can a board prove it prudently determined the correct contribution amount for the replacement reserve without an objective analysis?

If a major component fails, leading to a massive special assessment because the replacement reserve was inadequate, homeowners may sue the board for negligence and breach of fiduciary duty. The board's only defense will be to prove it acted with "ordinary prudence" and made informed decisions regarding the reserve funding.

A professional reserve study is that proof for a Kentucky board. It provides the objective, expert analysis needed to determine the appropriate funding level for the legally required replacement reserve ², fulfilling the board's fiduciary duty and providing a crucial liability shield.

What are the Benefits of a Reserve Study? The 4 Key Pillars for Kentucky Communities

For Kentucky communities, the benefits of proactively commissioning a reserve study extend beyond simply meeting the minimum legal funding requirement.

Benefit 1: Fulfilling Legal Requirements & Avoiding Special Assessments

A reserve study's primary function in Kentucky is to provide the data needed to comply with KRS 381.870's requirement to fund a replacement reserve.² It shifts planning from reactive to proactive. The alternative is levying "sudden, hefty" special assessments or securing costly bank loans when components fail—potentially signaling that the board failed to adequately plan for the required reserve. In Kentucky, boards have the power to levy special assessments for emergency repairs that exceed insurance coverage, but relying on this mechanism instead of proactive funding can be risky.

Furthermore, the "special assessment" model is fundamentally inequitable. For example: A roof has a 20-year life. "Fred" lives there for 18 years while the board contributes minimally to the reserve. Fred sells to "Bill." Two years later, the roof fails, and the underfunded reserve requires a large special assessment. Bill pays for 20 years of roof wear despite living there only two years. A reserve study provides an "equitable funding plan," ensuring all owners contribute fairly over time.

Benefit 2: Protect and Increase HOA Property Values in Kentucky

A reserve study acts as a critical "maintenance planning tool". By ensuring adequate funds are available for the replacement reserve ², the association can execute repairs and replacements on schedule, preventing "deferred maintenance". Well-maintained common areas and amenities directly correlate with higher and more stable property values in Kentucky communities.³ One analysis found that property values in communities with poorly managed, low reserve funds drop significantly.

Benefit 3: Meet Lender Requirements (Fannie Mae & FHA) & Resale Disclosures

A home's value is tied to a buyer's ability to get a mortgage. Lenders like Fannie Mae and FHA have strict requirements regarding an association's financial health. Fannie Mae requires lenders to review reserve adequacy, and FHA often requires 10% of income be allocated to reserves.

In Kentucky, this intersects with disclosure laws. KRS 381.9203 requires the resale disclosure certificate to state the "total reserve amount the association has for capital expenditures, if any".¹ Additionally, the standard Kentucky Seller's Disclosure of Property Condition (required by KRS 324.360) asks if the property is subject to HOA rules and the yearly assessment amount. An association disclosing low or non-existent reserves (despite the legal requirement to fund them) raises red flags for buyers and lenders, potentially making units ineligible for conventional loans and reducing market value.⁶

Benefit 4: Provide an Objective Roadmap for Future Kentucky Boards

Finally, for a Kentucky board, the reserve study is an essential governance tool. "Property managers come and go; board members frequently change, and the existing reserve study is there to help new decision makers understand the logic or reasoning behind earlier choices".

The study provides an "unbiased and objective" roadmap. Budget decisions, especially regarding the legally required reserve contributions ², can be political. A professional study "de-politicizes" this, allowing the board to state it is fulfilling its fiduciary duty by following an expert's plan to meet legal obligations and protect community assets.

What is a Reserve Study? The Two Essential Parts

While the study itself is not mandated by Kentucky law, it is the standard tool for determining the funding level for the legally required "replacement reserve" (KRS 381.870).¹ A professional reserve study includes a physical analysis and a financial analysis.³

Part 1: The Physical Analysis (What We Inspect)

This involves a "visual, non-invasive evaluation" by a specialist to assess the common property.³ It includes:

1. Component Inventory: A list of major common area components the association must repair or replace.³
2. Condition Assessment: Evaluation of each component's current physical condition.⁹
3. Life & Valuation Estimates: Assigning Useful Life (UL) and Remaining Useful Life (RUL), and estimating current Replacement Cost.¹¹

Part 2: The Financial Analysis (The Funding Plan)

This translates physical data into a financial "roadmap", analyzing reserve income and expenses.³ It includes:

1. Fund Status: A snapshot of current reserve health, often using "Percent Funded".⁴
2. Funding Plan: The core recommendation—a multi-year plan projecting income and expenses ¹², providing a stable contribution amount for the budget to meet future needs, including the required replacement reserve.²

How to Read a Reserve Study: 2 Key Metrics Explained

For a Kentucky board, focusing on these metrics helps understand the association's financial health regarding its replacement reserve obligations.²

Metric 1: What is "Percent Funded" in a Reserve Study?

"Percent Funded" measures reserve fund strength.¹³ It is calculated as:

$$\text{Percent Funded} = \frac{\text{Reserve Fund Balance (actual cash on hand)}}{\text{Fully Funded Balance (computed deterioration)}}$$

This formula is based on methodology described in ¹³ and.⁷ "100% Funded" means the reserve balance equals the computed value of asset deterioration, not the total replacement cost of all assets today.¹³

This metric provides a clear risk profile ¹³:

• Strong (> 70% Funded): Low risk of special assessments.¹³
• Fair (30% - 70% Funded): Moderate risk.¹³
• Weak (< 30% Funded): High risk of special assessments and deferred maintenance.¹³

Metric 2: Choosing a Funding Goal (Full, Threshold, or Baseline)

A reserve study presents funding goals, defining acceptable risk levels ¹⁵:

• Baseline Funding: Aims to keep the reserve balance just above $0.¹⁵ High risk, rarely recommended.¹⁵
• Full Funding: Aims to attain/maintain reserves near 100% funded.¹⁵ Most conservative, lowest risk.¹⁵
• Threshold Funding: Aims to keep the balance above a set minimum (e.g., 30% funded).¹⁵ Balanced approach, commonly recommended.¹⁶

StrategyPrimary GoalRisk of Special AssessmentTypical Contribution LevelFull FundingAttain/maintain ~100% funded status ¹⁵

Very Low ¹⁵

Most Conservative / Highest ¹⁹

Threshold Funding

Keep reserve balance above a set minimum ¹⁵

Managed / Moderate ¹⁵

Moderate / BalancedBaseline Funding

Keep reserve balance above $0 ¹⁵

High ¹⁵

Most Aggressive / Lowest ¹⁵

How to Implement a Reserve Study: A 5-Step Guide for Kentucky Boards

For a Kentucky board using a study to guide its required reserve funding, the process involves these steps ³:

Step 1: Understand the 3 Levels of a Reserve Study

Know what to ask for. National standards define three levels ²⁰:

• Level I (Full Study): The essential first study. Involves full on-site inspection and inventory creation.²¹
• Level II (Update with Site Visit): Periodic update (every 3-5 years recommended), specialist verifies inventory and re-assesses conditions on-site.²⁰
• Level III (Update, No Site Visit): Financial-only update for off-years.²⁰

Step 2: Pass a Board Resolution and Prepare Documents

Formally resolve to commission the study.⁷ Gather essential documents ²²: Governing Documents (defining maintenance responsibilities), budgets, and repair records.

Step 3: How to Hire a Credentialed Reserve Specialist

This is critical. Perform due diligence. Look for:

• Credentials: RS (Reserve Specialist) from CAI or PRA (Professional Reserve Analyst) from APRA.²³ These require experience and adherence to standards.²⁵
• Standards: Adherence to CAI National Reserve Study Standards.¹⁰
• Insurance: Proof of professional liability (Errors & Omissions) insurance.²²

Step 4: The Kick-Off Meeting and On-Site Inspection

Schedule a kickoff meeting and on-site inspection.⁷ Ensure someone knowledgeable accompanies the specialist.²² This is the "Physical Analysis".³

Step 5: Review the Draft Report and Adopt the Funding Plan

Review the draft for factual errors.¹⁰ Formally vote to adopt the study and implement its funding plan into the next annual budget.⁷ This demonstrates prudent action toward meeting the state's replacement reserve requirement.²

Why a Reserve Study is a Critical Investment for Your Kentucky Community

For a Kentucky HOA or condo, a reserve study isn't just a best practice; it's the most reliable tool for fulfilling the state's legal requirement to fund a replacement reserve (KRS 381.870) ² and upholding the board's fiduciary duty.

In Kentucky, it is the mechanism that simultaneously:

• Provides the basis for funding the legally required replacement reserve.²
• Fulfills the board's fiduciary duty to act prudently and make informed decisions.
• Protects homeowners from inequitable special assessments.
• Preserves and enhances long-term property values.³
• Ensures accurate resale disclosures (KRS 381.9203) ¹ and marketability to buyers and lenders.

A Kentucky board that proactively commissions a reserve study demonstrates responsible, sophisticated management, ensuring compliance with state law and securing the community's financial future.

‍